Key Takeaways:

  • 401k hardship withdrawals are allowed under IRS guidelines for specific immediate financial needs.
  • Alternatives such as loans from a 401(k) or IRAs should be considered before withdrawing.
  • New IRS guidelines allow penalty-free withdrawals in certain hardship situations.
  • Proof of hardship requirements vary but often require self-certification or plan administrator review.
  • Tax and financial impacts include early withdrawal penalties, income tax liabilities, and lost retirement growth.
  • Repayment restrictions apply, and contributions to the plan may be paused for a certain period.
  • Other financial options like home equity loans, personal loans, or financial assistance programs may be better alternatives.

What is 401k Hardship Withdrawal?

A 401k hardship withdrawal is included in most 401k retirement plans – but not all of them are required to. Internal Revenue Service (IRS) rules state that hardship withdrawals are only permitted if it is needed to satisfy “an immediate and heavy financial need, and limited to the amount necessary to satisfy that financial need.” Financial needs of a 401k holder’s beneficiaries can satisfy this requirement.

To make a hardship withdrawal, an employee must have already obtained any other income available under the 401k plan. After making a hardship withdrawal, an employee can't contribute to their 401k plan for six months.

The IRS allows hardship withdrawals for:

  • Unreimbursed medical expenses of an employee or the employee’s spouse or dependents
  • The employee’s housing needs (rent, mortgage payment, or real estate purchase)
  • Tuition
  • Certain other necessary expenses

Income tax must be paid on amounts gained through hardship withdrawals. Those under 59 ½ years old also need to pay a 10 percent penalty for early withdrawal.

Recent Changes to 401k Hardship Withdrawal Rules

The SECURE 2.0 Act has introduced new provisions that make it easier to access 401(k) funds for hardship reasons. Some of these changes include the ability to withdraw funds for emergency personal expenses without a mandatory six-month contribution suspension. Additionally, plan sponsors now have more flexibility in defining hardship scenarios. Be sure to check with your plan administrator to see if your employer has adopted these new provisions.

A Couple of Other Notes

It should be remembered that hardship withdrawal rules only apply when an employee is still working for the sponsor of the 401k. Once an employee is separated from their 401k sponsor, the hardship rules do not apply.

When is a 401k Hardship Withdrawal Allowed?

As long as the IRS criteria are met, a hardship withdrawal is allowed whenever the employer allows for it.

Hardship Basics

Hardship withdrawals are different than plan loans. They are more difficult to get, and more costly. They should only be taken if truly needed and there are no better financial options available.

Early withdrawal penalties can be avoided, however, if a person becomes totally disabled, if their medical debts exceed 7.5 percent of their Adjusted Gross Income, or if the money is needed to fulfill court ordered spousal or child support. Also, there is on penalty for those separated from their 401k sponsor after the age of 55.

Pros and Cons of a 401k Hardship Withdrawal

While a hardship withdrawal can provide quick financial relief, it comes with significant drawbacks. Consider these before making a decision:

Pros:

  • Immediate access to funds in an emergency
  • No need for credit approval, unlike a traditional loan
  • No obligation to repay the funds

Cons:

  • Subject to income tax and a 10% early withdrawal penalty if under 59 ½
  • Loss of potential investment growth
  • Potential six-month suspension of future 401(k) contributions
  • Reduction in retirement savings

If you're considering a hardship withdrawal, consult a financial professional to assess whether it's the best option.

Proof of Hardship

Employees must prove that they meet the hardship requirements laid out by the IRS in order to make a hardship withdrawal. Proof can be provided in the form of a financial disclosure, but self-certification is also permitted.  In most cases, a plan administrator can make this determination without undertaking a lengthy inquiry.

How to Qualify for a 401k Hardship Withdrawal

To qualify for a hardship withdrawal, you must demonstrate an immediate and heavy financial need. Employers may require one or more of the following forms of proof:

  • Medical bills, eviction notices, or tuition invoices
  • Legal documents verifying a court-ordered expense
  • Funeral expenses for a dependent
  • Documentation of home damage from natural disasters

Some plans allow self-certification, meaning the employee attests to the hardship without submitting detailed documentation. However, rules may vary by employer.

Loan Alternative

As soon as money is taken out of a 401k, it is taxed and cannot be returned. There is no “paying back” a hardship withdrawal. Once the withdrawal takes place, all the advantages the 401k offered evaporate.

That is why employees should avoid hardship withdrawals whenever possible. Some plans offer 401k loans, and these are almost always preferable. This is because loans are not taxed as income.

Plan holders should also consider taking out a loan from the IRA plan if they have one as an alternative to making a 401k hardship withdrawal.

When a 401(k) Loan May Be a Better Option

In many cases, taking a 401(k) loan is a better alternative than a hardship withdrawal. Here’s why:

  • No Immediate Taxes or Penalties: A loan is not taxed as income and avoids the 10% penalty.
  • Repayment to Your Account: Unlike hardship withdrawals, 401(k) loans allow you to repay the borrowed amount, keeping your retirement savings intact.
  • Lower Interest Costs: The interest paid goes back into your retirement account, not to a lender.

However, if you leave your job before repaying the loan, the remaining balance may be due immediately or treated as an early withdrawal, triggering taxes and penalties.

Tax Pain

Don’t overlook taxes. Think about this cost before taking out a hardship withdrawal to make sure it is really financially worth it to you.

Taxes and Opportunity Costs

When withdrawals come from Roth IRA contributions, employees usually won’t pay income taxes on that money aside from any portion that comes from employer contributions.

Retirement Pain

Also, don’t overlook the impact that making an early withdrawal can have on your retirement plan.

Should You Use a 401k Hardship Withdrawal?

  • A 401k hardship withdrawal should be a last resort. Making an early withdrawal severely and permanently reduces your retirement fund. You will also miss out on any interest that you would have otherwise earned.
  • It should also be remembered that creditors cannot touch 401k money, and 401k funds are protected from bankruptcy. If someone is thinking about filing for bankruptcy, they should not take money out of their 401k.
  • Because there are such severe costs to a making a 401k early withdrawal, it is almost always better to loan money from other lenders when possible.

Allowed Amount of Hardship Withdrawals

A hardship withdrawal cannot be more than the total amount of the employee contributions. And as mentioned, it cannot exceed the amount needed to satisfy the financial need.

After You Take a 401(k) Hardship Withdrawal

After taking out a 401k hardship withdrawal, an employee cannot make new contributions to their 401k for the next six months. Even after that six-month period, there is no “paying back” the withdrawn money. Contributions can continue after six months have passed, but taxes on the withdrawn money still need to be paid.

Long-Term Impact on Your Retirement

A hardship withdrawal can significantly reduce your retirement savings due to:

  • Lost Compound Interest: Funds withdrawn lose the opportunity for market growth.
  • Reduced Employer Matching: If your contributions are suspended, you may miss out on employer-matching contributions.
  • Higher Future Contribution Needs: You may need to increase contributions later to compensate for the lost funds.

It’s essential to have a plan to rebuild your retirement savings after taking a hardship withdrawal.

Other Options

It could be a better option to take funds out of a college savings plan for children before a 401k. Most college savings plans do not charge an early withdrawal fee. Taking out any type of loan is usually preferable. Refinancing a mortgage is another option.

Alternative Financial Resources to Consider

Before taking a hardship withdrawal, consider these alternatives:

  • Emergency Savings: If you have a cash reserve, use it first.
  • Home Equity Line of Credit (HELOC): A lower-interest option compared to personal loans.
  • Credit Counseling Services: Nonprofit financial advisors can help manage debt without depleting retirement savings.
  • Government Assistance Programs: Programs like Medicaid, unemployment benefits, or food assistance can provide temporary relief without long-term financial repercussions.

Taking a 401(k) hardship withdrawal should always be the last resort.

Frequently Asked Questions:

1. How do I know if my hardship qualifies for a 401(k) withdrawal? A qualifying hardship must meet IRS guidelines for an immediate and heavy financial need. Common examples include medical expenses, tuition, foreclosure prevention, or funeral costs.

2. What taxes will I pay on a 401(k) hardship withdrawal? You will owe ordinary income tax on the withdrawn amount, plus a 10% early withdrawal penalty if under 59 ½, unless an exemption applies.

3. Can I repay a 401(k) hardship withdrawal? No, hardship withdrawals are not loans and cannot be repaid. Once withdrawn, the funds are permanently removed from your retirement savings.

4. How long does it take to process a hardship withdrawal? Processing times vary by employer, but most hardship withdrawals are reviewed and approved within 7-14 business days.

5. What happens if I take multiple hardship withdrawals? Frequent hardship withdrawals can deplete retirement savings, reduce employer contributions, and increase overall tax liabilities. It’s essential to explore other financial options first.

If you need help with your 401k, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel’s marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.