Key Takeaways

  • Sole Proprietorship vs LLC: Sole proprietorships are simpler and cheaper to set up, but LLCs offer liability protection and tax flexibility.
  • Liability Protection: LLCs shield personal assets from business debts, unlike sole proprietorships, where the owner is personally responsible.
  • Taxation Differences: Both business structures offer pass-through taxation, but LLCs can choose corporate taxation for potential savings.
  • Startup and Compliance Costs: Sole proprietorships are inexpensive to start, while LLCs require registration, annual fees, and compliance.
  • Funding and Growth: LLCs have greater access to funding and investors, while sole proprietorships often rely on personal savings or loans.
  • Business Credibility: An LLC may provide more legitimacy and professionalism to clients and investors compared to a sole proprietorship.
  • When to Choose Which: Sole proprietorships work well for low-risk, one-person businesses, while LLCs suit businesses seeking liability protection and scalability.

California sole proprietorship vs LLC is a common consideration among aspiring business owners in California as they decide which business structure to adopt. A sole proprietorship refers to a business with a single human owner, while a limited liability company (LLC) is a company with one or more owners, who are also called members. Both of these business structures have their pros and cons.

Choosing a Legal Entity for Your Business

When you are choosing a legal entity for your business, you need to consider many things, including:

  • State and federal tax laws
  • Liability protection
  • Ownership structure
  • Management goals
  • Investment and funding considerations
  • Exit strategies

Doing proper planning in advance can help you avoid the need to restructure your business later, which can incur a lot of time, effort, and money.

California Sole Proprietorship Vs LLC

In California, you are allowed to conduct business as a sole proprietor or LLC, but not both. When you are choosing between sole proprietorship and LLC, you should take two key differences into consideration: liability and taxes. A sole proprietorship provides no legal separation between itself and its owner. The owner will receive all its profits and be accountable for all its losses and debts.

An LLC, on the other hand, gives its members limited liability, protecting them from being held personally liable for its financial obligations. A sole proprietorship and an LLC are typically taxed similarly because the IRS considers a single-member LLC a disregarded entity. A single-member LLC usually reports its income and expenses on its members' IRS Form 1040, the way a sole proprietorship does.

People who prefer to be their own boss might benefit from a sole proprietorship or single-member LLC. This provides the opportunity to handle all management, finance, marketing, and policies of the business. There is no need to wait for approval from other owners or consult with anyone else if you are a sole proprietor or owner in a single-member LLC.

Those who are not experienced business owners might prefer to collaborate with others on important business decisions. Having other members can help you learn from their experiences, distribute marketing and management duties, and there may be additional funding opportunities.

Liability Protection in Sole Proprietorship vs LLC

One of the most significant distinctions between a sole proprietorship vs LLC is liability protection. A sole proprietor is personally responsible for all business debts and legal actions against the business. This means that personal assets, such as savings, a home, or a vehicle, could be at risk in the event of a lawsuit or unpaid debts.

In contrast, an LLC (Limited Liability Company) provides a legal separation between the business and its owners (members). If the LLC is sued or incurs debt, only the assets of the business are at risk, not the personal assets of the owners—except in cases where personal guarantees were made or if the corporate veil is pierced due to fraudulent activities.

Pros and Cons of a Sole Proprietorship

Pros

  • Easy Formation — As a sole proprietor, you can start your business very easily and quickly since you do not have to file documents or deal with government procedures. However, you are required to file a “Doing Business As” (DBA) name if you do not want to name your business after your legal name. All you need to do to get your business started is obtain the necessary licenses and permits.
  • Flexibility — Sole proprietorship also gives you a lot of flexibility, allowing you to customize your ownership and management structures.
  • Pass-Through Taxation — One of the most important benefits of a sole proprietorship is that it has a pass-through tax structure. For federal tax purposes, its income is reported and taxed on its owner's individual tax return.
  • Minimal Recordkeeping and Compliance Requirements — In addition, a sole proprietorship does not have to submit annual reports or pay annual fees to the state. Besides keeping records for tax purposes, it is also not required to meet any specific accounting requirements.

Cons

  • Personal Liability — A major disadvantage of a sole proprietorship is that it does not separate your business and personal assets. Your personal assets may be accessible to creditors if you fail to pay your debts. As such, it exposes you to greater risks. With a sole proprietorship, you and the business are viewed as a single entity, which means your personal liability for all the liabilities and debts of the sole proprietorship is unlimited.
  • Difficulty in Securing Funding — As a sole proprietor, you will have to use your personal resources or seek out loans to fund your business. If you are a new entrepreneur, it may be difficult for you to get a line of credit or loan from a bank. Usually, you will have to provide a personal guarantee in order to secure a loan for your business.
  • State Franchise Tax — California requires a state filing, and it is required to pay the State Franchise Tax, which is a minimum of $800 per year, due at the end of the first quarter.
  • Reduction in Funding or Value — Because sole proprietorship business assets are accessible to claims of personal creditors, the value of the business may be reduced, or you may have difficulty raising capital.
  • Sole Proprietorships Can Cease to Exist — If you bring in additional investors or transfer any assets to another buyer, it will cause the sole proprietorship to end. You may find that there is a restriction on transferring licenses, contracts, or other business assets to another entity or buyer.

Pros and Cons of a California LLC

Pros

  • Personal Liability Protection — The main benefit of an LLC is that it separates its debts from your personal assets. If your LLC is sued, the plaintiff can only access the LLC's assets, not your personal assets, if he or she wins.
  • Pass-Through Taxation — Additionally, an LLC is also a pass-through entity, allowing allocated profits to flow through to its members' individual income tax returns. An LLC with partnership or S corporation classification may also have a pass-through tax structure.
  • Greater Availability of Funds and Resources — As a member of an LLC, you can bring in new members to fund the company. With more members, you will also have access to more resources and contacts.

Cons

  • More Formation Requirements — Starting a California LLC is more difficult as it requires you to register with the California Secretary of State. You are also required to draft and submit the Articles of Organization to the Secretary of State and pay a filing fee.
  • Assets are Reachable by Creditors — Although your personal assets are protected in a lawsuit if the LLC is sued, whatever assets you contributed to the LLC are available to judgment creditors, but at least the risk is usually capped.

Operating Flexibility and Management Differences

While both business structures allow the owner to run operations independently, they differ in terms of management structure and regulatory requirements.

  • Sole Proprietorship: The business owner has full control over all decisions without needing approval from partners or members. This allows for fast decision-making but may lead to challenges in scaling the business.
  • LLC: Can be managed by its members (owners) or appoint managers to oversee operations. This structure is particularly beneficial when multiple people are involved in the business, ensuring operational continuity if one member leaves.

An LLC also benefits from having an Operating Agreement, which outlines member roles, responsibilities, and decision-making processes, helping prevent conflicts in multi-member businesses.

How to Establish an LLC

In order to set up an LLC, you have to form and register the business with the applicable state agency, which is usually the Secretary of State's office. You need to draft and file your articles of organization and pay the applicable filing fee, which could be hundreds of dollars in some states. Your filing information typically includes information like:

  • LLC name
  • Owner or members names
  • Main office location
  • Intended term of the LLC
  • Any other information mandated by state

If you have two or more members in your LLC, it's recommended to speak with a skilled legal professional in order to draft a comprehensive operating agreement that includes important details like capital contributions, members' duties, and the rights to profits. Setting up an LLC takes more time, effort, and money versus a sole proprietorship, so factor that in when deciding on which business entity is right for you.

Review your investment potential, financial resources, and credit history to determine whether you can start a business as a sole proprietorship or if you will need more resources that bringing in other partners would provide. If you consider starting an LLC with other members, you can pool resources and money to increase your potential network reach and help you fund your new business.

You will need to determine how you want your LLC to be taxed. LLCs are considered a pass-through entity, which means profits are taxed on each member's individual tax returns. Federal income tax treatment is similar, which means this factor may not be as important when deciding between a sole proprietorship or LLC.

Additional Compliance and Recordkeeping Responsibilities

Forming and maintaining an LLC requires additional compliance compared to a sole proprietorship. California LLCs must adhere to:

  • Annual Reporting Requirements: LLCs must file a Statement of Information with the California Secretary of State every two years, disclosing essential business details.
  • Franchise Tax: LLCs must pay a minimum $800 annual franchise tax, regardless of profitability. Sole proprietors are not subject to this tax.
  • Recordkeeping: LLCs are required to maintain meeting minutes and financial records to uphold liability protection, whereas sole proprietors do not have formal recordkeeping obligations beyond tax documentation.

Despite these requirements, many business owners opt for LLC status to gain liability protection and credibility, which often outweighs the additional administrative effort.

What Are Federal and State Taxes That Both LLCs and Sole Proprietorships Must Adhere To?

No matter what type of business entity you decide on, you will always need to pay federal tax and California state income tax on your business income. The IRS and the state both tax a single-member LLC in the same manner as a sole proprietorship. If you opt to hire employees and have to pay employment taxes or excise taxes, the LLC will be responsible for the payments, not the single owner. This is why it's recommended to apply for a Federal Employer Identification Number (EIN).

By forming an LLC, you have the option to have business income taxed like a traditional corporation. Without choosing the corporate election, all business income would be added to your personal returns whereas a corporation allows you to file a separate corporate tax return.

Tax Flexibility and IRS Treatment of LLCs

One of the advantages of an LLC over a sole proprietorship is its tax classification flexibility. By default, a single-member LLC is taxed like a sole proprietorship, with profits flowing through to the owner's personal tax return. However, LLCs have the option to elect S-Corp or C-Corp taxation, which can provide benefits such as:

  • Lower Self-Employment Taxes: By electing S-Corp status, an LLC owner can classify part of their earnings as a salary and take the remainder as distributions, potentially reducing self-employment taxes.
  • Retained Earnings: Unlike a sole proprietorship, an LLC electing C-Corp taxation can retain earnings within the company instead of distributing all profits, which can aid in reinvestment and growth.

While sole proprietorships provide simpler tax filing, they do not offer the same flexibility that LLCs have in structuring tax obligations.

Other Types of Business Entities Available

There are several other types of business entities in addition to a sole proprietorship or LLC in California. One of these is a general partnership. This doesn't require any state filings and also offers pass-through taxation. Partners are jointly and severally liable for the partnership's debts, which means each partner is liable for the full debt until it's completely paid off.

Limited Partnership

Another business type is the limited partnership (LP), which has more formal requirements, including a filing with the California Secretary of State, a thorough partnership agreement, and the LP must hold annual meetings. Limited partners are typically just passive investors while general partners handle management duties. Limited partners' liability is typically limited to their investment amount while general partners have unlimited liability. Limited partnerships are also required to pay the California Franchise Tax.

Limited Liability Partnership

California also offers an LLP, or limited liability partnership. This is only available for certain professionals like architects, lawyers, or accountants. Each partner in an LLP shares in liability for partnership debts, but each one is protected from individual liability that arises from another partner's actions. If a partner engages in a wrongful activity like fraud, he or she will be personally liable for the misconduct.

Professional LLCs and Industry-Specific Considerations

Certain professionals, such as lawyers, accountants, and architects, may be required to form a Professional LLC (PLLC) instead of a standard LLC. A PLLC follows the same principles as a standard LLC but must comply with state regulations governing professional services.

Additionally, some industries may have restrictions on sole proprietorships or LLCs based on licensing requirements. Before choosing a business structure, it's important to verify state licensing laws that may impact your ability to operate as a sole proprietor or an LLC.

C and S Corporations

C corporations are also subject to the State Franchise Tax and must file with the state. There is a lot more recordkeeping involved and all assets must be held separately. Shareholders have liability protection, but the limited liability is not ironclad. There are instances where someone may “pierce the corporate veil” which would open shareholders up to personal liability. Shareholders in an S corporation are ones who elect to be taxed as a pass-through entity. There are very specific requirements on what corporations qualify for S corporation status.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. Is an LLC always better than a sole proprietorship?
    Not necessarily. LLCs provide liability protection and tax flexibility but come with higher costs and compliance requirements. Sole proprietorships are easier and cheaper to start but expose the owner to personal liability.
  2. How much does it cost to start an LLC in California?
    California requires an $70 LLC formation filing fee and an $800 annual franchise tax. Additional fees may apply for name registration, operating agreements, and business licenses.
  3. Can I convert a sole proprietorship into an LLC later?
    Yes, many business owners start as sole proprietors and later transition to an LLC as their business grows. This involves filing formation documents with the California Secretary of State and updating business registrations.
  4. Does an LLC pay more taxes than a sole proprietorship?
    LLCs have more tax options. While default taxation is similar (pass-through taxation), an LLC can elect S-Corp or C-Corp status, potentially reducing self-employment taxes. Sole proprietors have fewer tax structuring options.
  5. Which business structure is better for getting a loan?
    LLCs may have better access to loans and investor funding since they are legally distinct from their owners. Sole proprietors rely more on personal credit and assets to secure financing.

If you need help with choosing between California sole proprietorship and LLC, you can post your need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.